Skip to main content

The controversy over autism’s most common therapy

When Lisa Quinones-Fontanez’s son Norrin was diagnosed with autism at age 2, she and her husband did what most parents in their position do — they scrambled to form a plan to help their child.
Ultimately, they followed the experts’ advice. They put Norrin in a school that used applied behavioral analysis, or ABA, the longest-standing and best-established form of therapy for children with autism. They also hired an ABA therapist to direct a home program.
ABA involves as much as 40 hours a week of one-on-one therapy. Certified therapists deliver or oversee the regimen, organized around the child’s individual needs — developing social skills, for instance, and learning to write a name or use the bathroom. The approach breaks desirable behaviors down into steps and rewards the child for completing each step along the way.
Bijou contemplated using similar strategies in people, judging that verbal rewards — saying “good job,” for instance — would serve as adequate motivation. But it was Lovaas who would put this idea into practice.
In 1970, Lovaas launched the Young Autism Project at the University of California, Los Angeles, with the aim of applying behaviorist methods to children with autism. The project established the methods and goals that grew into ABA. Part of the agenda was to make the child as ‘normal’ as possible, by teaching behaviors such as hugging and looking someone in the eye for a sustained period of time — both of which children with autism tend to avoid, making them visibly different.
Michael Powers, director of the Center for Children With Special Needs in Glastonbury, Connecticut, started his career working at a school for children with autism in New Jersey in the 1970s. The therapist would sit on one side of a table, the child on the other. Together, they went through a scripted process to teach a given skill — over and over until the child had mastered it.
“We were doing that because it was the only thing that worked at the time,” Powers says. “The techniques of teaching autistic kids hadn’t evolved enough to branch out yet.” Looking back, he sees flaws, such as requiring children to maintain eye contact for an uncomfortably long period of time. “Five seconds. That was one skill we were trying to establish, as if that was the pivotal skill,” he says. But it was artificial: “The last time I looked someone in the eye for five consecutive seconds, I proposed.”
Doubts grew about how useful these skills were in the real world — whether children could transfer what they’d learned with a therapist to a natural environment. A child might know when to look a therapist in the eye at the table, especially with prompts and a reward, but still not know what to do in a social situation.
The aversive training components of the therapy also drew criticism. Many found the idea of punishing children for ‘bad’ behavior such as hand-flapping and vocal outbursts hard to stomach.
Each type of ABA is often packaged with other treatments, such as speech or occupational therapy, so that no two children’s programs may look alike. “It’s like a Chinese buffet,” says Fred Volkmar, Irving B. Harris Professor of Child Psychiatry, Pediatrics and Psychology at the Yale University Child Study Center and lead author of “Evidence-Based Practices and Treatments for Children with Autism,” a book many consider the go-to reference for ABA. Apart from this NDIS occupational therapy is also for this case.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ultimate Beginner Guide for Guitar Lovers (Basic Tips)

  1)Acoustic guitars:   Acoustic guitar generates sound without an exterternal power supply- specially known for its organic and warm tones. The tones generally vary based on the body size, wood type, and craftsmanship. 2)Electric guitars:  Electric Guitars are heavy in general and are well-known for their versatility in pop, jazz, blues, and rock. It requires amplifiers and pedals to produce sound like distortion, reverb, delay, and more. Now, go  grab your fit . You must also know about the  guitar parts  as well. Tuning and Care: It’s important to know how to tune your guitar before you start performing. You can use a tuner or  tuning app . Also, cleaning and string changes are critical for better sound and the health of your instrument. Practice is the key: It takes time, patience, and constant practice to learn to deal with finger pain and chord transition. You have to be very consistent and add it to your daily routine. Explore learning reso...

Green Strings: Are Eco-Friendly Guitar Strings a Thing Yet?

  For guitarists, string changes are a regular ritual. Whether you’re a hobbyist or a professional musician, chances are you’ve gone through dozens—maybe hundreds—of sets over the years. But while we might lovingly preserve our instruments, upgrade our guitar bridge for better sustain, or treasure a vintage guitar tailpiece, our discarded strings usually end up in the trash. It’s an environmental blind spot. Strings are small, seemingly insignificant—but multiply that by millions of musicians worldwide, and the waste starts to add up. Which brings us to a pressing, planet-conscious question: Are eco-friendly guitar strings a thing yet? What Makes Guitar Strings Unsustainable? When it comes to sustainability in music gear, guitar strings often fly under the radar. Yet they’re one of the most frequently replaced items in a guitarist’s toolkit. Unlike the core  guitar parts  —such as the guitar bridge, tailpiece, or bridge saddles—strings have a short lifespan and are design...

How To Setup Gibson Les Paul Bridge – Installation Guide

  The Gibson Les Paul is a classic electric guitar that has been a favorite of guitarists for generations. One of the most important components of the Les Paul is the bridge, which plays a crucial role in determining the guitar’s sound and playability. Here, we’ll be discussing a step-by-step guide on how to set up a Gibson Les Paul bridge, with a focus on the Tune-O-Matic bridge and its components, such as the guitar bridge saddles and  guitar tailpiece . Before we get started, it’s important to have a basic understanding of the parts of a  guitar bridge . The bridge is part of the guitar that holds the strings in place and allows for adjustments in string height and intonation. The Les Paul bridge, also known as the  Tune-O-Matic bridge , is a popular choice for many guitarists due to its high level of adjustability and ability to improve the guitar’s intonation. Step 1: Remove the old strings. Before installing the new bridge, you’ll need to remove the old strings...